Welcome to PacozDiscipline

I have a flair for making people & communities successful. I yearn to excel in that arena!

This is a compilation of my thoughts and responses to others thoughts. Most of them are relevant to the world of learning & development, and may be of help to you. Please add your comments and views.

Showing posts with label Feedback to Trainers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Feedback to Trainers. Show all posts

Monday, March 5, 2012

Target - Performance Improvement

My journey in the world of learning started more than a decade back. In the past decade, the first half was focused on learning & delivering, and the latter half is marked by learning, following AND facilitating. Whilst helping out others, I have always introduced with my note below which has been shamelessly inpired by Bob Mager's book, 'What Every Manager Should Know About Training'; and no, this is not plagiarism, but my effort to ensure that people, CEOs and CLOs, get the gist of the thought. My trademark 18-day 'Trainer BootCamp' starts with the concept of what training can / can not do, as mentioned in this note, and I have taken about 500 trainers through it during various bootcamps.

________________________________________________ __ __ __



Performance Improvement

is

the ‘T A R G E T’


Performance is key to a person’s success and that is integral to the organization’s success. However, the organization is always surrounded by challenges, which hinder performance. These Performance Challenges, specifically in the area of ‘the work’, ‘the worker’, and the ‘the work environment’, are a result of a measured disparity between the ‘desired’ and the ‘actual’ state of work performance or the expected disparity between the ‘desired’ and the ‘actual’ state of work performance.

This disparity, once broken down and analyzed, leads to a specific set of gaps. These gaps could be in the 3 specific areas, such as, knowledge gaps, skill gaps, and attitudinal gaps (including Motivation & Expectations).

These gaps could be handled in many a ways such as by giving Training interventions, Coaching interventions, Consulting interventions and Non-Training interventions. Training interventions help build the skills and self-efficacy in the trainees.


Skill

If people don’t know how to do it, they can’t do it. No amount of incentives or exhortations or threats will get them to do it. Without skill there can be no performance.

If they don’t know what to do and how to do it, and if they need to be able to do it, then someone will need to teach them to do it. But skills are not developed merely by listening to someone talk about how to perform. Skills are developed and strengthened through practice, through the actual doing of those work tasks.



Self-Efficacy

Self-efficacy refers to the judgments people make about their abilities to execute particular courses of action – about their ability to do specific things. For example, “I know I’m a good golfer;” “I know I can beat my sales record of last year;” “I know that my fencing skill is the best in town.”

Self-efficacy isn’t about the actual skills people have; it’s about the judgments they make about the strength of those skills. People with low self-efficacy don’t believe they can do the things they actually can do. “Oh, well, I didn’t take the job offer because I didn’t think I was really good enough.”

Don’t confuse self-efficacy with self-confidence, which is a much more generalized way of referring to one’s feelings, and often refers to the expected outcomes of one’s actions.

Why is self-efficacy so important?

When people don’t judge themselves able to do something they actually can do, they may not even try to do it. They may avoid trying, regardless of the strength of their skills. Therefore, if people are given the skills they need, but not the self-efficacy, they will be unlikely to perform those skills on the job. No self-efficacy, no performance.

There’s more. People with strong self-efficacy will not only be more willing to try, they will be more willing to persist in the face of obstacles, failures, or embarrassment. They are less likely to give up in the face of adversity. Thus, strong self-efficacy makes people less vulnerable to on-the-job conditions that aren’t always supportive. How can you get people to “try, try again” in the face of difficulties or failures? Make sure you (and anyone training others) apply efficacy-strengthening techniques.

Unfortunately, the development of a skill isn’t automatically accompanied by a development of strong self-efficacy. You may recall instances in which people with great deal of skills didn’t believe they had the degree of skill they did. You’ve probably seen people hang back because of a lack of self-efficacy rather than because of a lack of skill.

"When people don’t judge themselves able to do something they actually can do, they may not even try to do it…"


Opportunity to Perform

Without the opportunity to perform, there will be no performance. Opportunity means being provided with items such as:

  • The permission (or authority) to perform
  • Information about expectations
  • Tools and equipment needed to perform
  • A place in which to perform
  • The time to perform

If you were an accomplished sitar-player but didn’t have a sitar, you wouldn’t be able to perform sitar solos. No sitar, no performance. By the same token, if you had a sitar but lived in a state where playing the sitar is prohibited, you wouldn’t be able to perform (without running the risk of being caught by the anti-sitar police). If you don’t have the tools to do your job, or a place in which to do it, you won’t be able to perform. No opportunity, no performance.

But there’s more, because mere opportunity to perform is not enough.

 
You can’t store training! Use it or Lose it.    

Or, as the trainers say, use it or lose it. Unlike fine wines, skills do not improve merely with the passage of time. Think about the courses you took in school. Are you as sharp on each of those subjects as you were when the course ended? No? Why not? You’ve forgotten a lot of the information or skills because you haven’t used them – because you haven’t practiced them. Essentially, Use it or Lose it.


Supportive Environment

Suppose that every time you sat down to work on a budget, your boss came in and whacked you about the head and the shoulder with a rolled newspaper or showered you with verbal abuse. How long would you continue to work on budgets? Or, suppose that you were ridiculed by your peers every time you offered a suggestion at a meeting? How long would you continue to offer suggestions? Or, suppose that every time you made a worthwhile suggestion you were requires to head the committee organized to implement it? Or, suppose that every time you came in under budget, your budget was cut off for next year. No supportive environment, no performance.

A supportive environment is one that encourages desired performance. It is environment in which workers are given reasons (incentives) to perform in the desired manner, a clear description of the results to be obtained and the standards to be met; it is an environment which the employee’s world gets a little brighter when they do it right, and a little dimmer when they don’t. When the consequences of performing well are upside down – that is, punishments for doing it right or rewards for doing it wrong – desired performance will be difficult or impossible to sustain.

Performance then requires the presence of skill, self-efficacy, opportunity to perform, and a supportive environment. Take away any one of those ingredients and the performance will suffer, or worst, will never appear.

The diagram above although shows ‘interventions’ at a cross-section of gaps, however, it is just a diagrammatic representation.

Different types of gaps require to be treated in different ways. The ‘best way’ is the way in which the audience internalizes best and the one which impacts the learner’s performance as per the desired levels.


Gap Type                             Input Type

Knowledge                            Training, Non-Training

Skill                                        Training & Coaching

Attitude                                 Training, Coaching,
(including Motivations       Non-Training & Consulting
& Expectations)


We should remember that all forms of gaps are not trainable from a corporate perspective, wherein time does not have an infinite value.

One, however, needs to keep in mind that Training is not the only solution for all kinds of performance problems, however, the propensity of most ‘trainers’ is to resort to ‘training’ as a solution to one & all. It’s like giving paracetamol for all kinds of ailments.

Sunday, July 5, 2009

What are the dos and don'ts of giving other trainers feedback?

Andrew Calvert posed the above mentioned question (http://www.linkedin.com/answers/management/organizational-development/MGM_ODV/416428-4161241?browseIdx=16&sik=1246779891209&goback=%2Eama) on LinkedIn, to which the note mentioned below was my response. The reference made inline refer to all the posts made by others in the same post. I have also mentioned the answer selected by Andrew as the best answer; mine was selected as a good answer Everyone should benefit!!!
________________________________________________
MY ANSWER
People are observed so that they can be given feedback... and not just feedback, but 'articulating' ways to strengthen strengths and weaken weaknesses, that is to improve upon the current state of performance. So, whether we talk about a trainer or any other profile, the basic premise remains the same. I have done some work on this area, and am going to give a brief outline of the same. The most crucial aspect is to be clear & articulate the parameters to observe. Now, for a trainer (whilst facilitating a training program), there would be some activities which would be event-based (such as setting objectives as per Bloom's taxonomy prior to the beginning of the session), and some would be ongoing (not pointing a finger at the audience). The identification & articulation of these parameters in form of observable traits is key to the whole process. One could look at breaking down 'facilitation' competencies, or one could look at ready reckoners (if any available) of observable traits. The second most important thing is to articulate the Likert scale. I have picked up the scale of proficiency from Sharon Gander's OPIS (Outcome Proficiency Indicator Scale) and created a 7 pointer scale. Each point on the scale is well articulated, and is simple. The discrepancy, when used by and untrained eye, lies at about 13%, which is OK for the time being. The next most important thing is for the observer to be trained in observing. I have noticed many (read many many many many) observers, who do not write their observations; so, even if there is a detailed set of observable traits avaialble, one still needs to write the indicators, so that the same could be used to give feedback, hence making the process non-controversial. Most observers observe and then write in hindsight, making the entire observation subjective to the extent of what I think is the best or worst component of the 'performance', and the other biggest deterrent for the entire process is the involvement of memory in the entire process. When written after the even is over, it is a matter of 'how much I remember', which is unjustified for the person being observed. This is one of the primary reasons that even after giving repeated feedback sessions, trainers are not able to maintain their proficiency scores for they focus on improving only, and lose sight of maintaing the appropriate behaviors. The next step is to give the feedback, and that is where most coaches fail. So, there are three types of feedback-providers. a) those who give 'back-feed' rather than 'feed-back'... those who just complain all the things that were not done (this includes all those who sugar-coat and give feedback); b) those who give feed-back in the way that it is supposed to be given... 'sandwhich' technique (includes those who give feed-back the 'executive coach' style), and c) the least done... not only giving feedback, but also helping out by telling as to how to improve, and even going all the way to demonstrating. The 'c' category are the ones who should be allowed while giving functional coaching (especially), and 'facilitating a training' falls under that category. The last step in the entire process is 'review'. If a review is not done, then the entire process falls through the crack, and people tend to revert to doing whatever one was doing, because imbibing new traits makes one uncomfortable, and unknowingly one tends to revert to the same, especially when there is no review mechanism available. The parameters that I had used had a huge contribution from Anand Dewan, the Likert Scale used was an excerpt from Sharon Gander's research, and the operationalising aspect of the tool was jointly done by Rajesh Krishnan and Me. The tool has been applied on ~400 trainers for atleast 6 sessions each and each session had atleast 50 observations parameters observed on the 7-point proficiency scale.

BEST ANSWER
I agree with many of the comments here, and I would add that I have found feedback is most successful when
*The observer acts as an event participant. When an observer sits or stands outside the room, walks in and out, behaves as if they are there strictly to observe, or worse yet takes over for the facilitator--it can be distracting to both facilitator and event participants. The point is to get a realistic view of the facilitator skills and help them to improve. The best way to do that is to simply take on the participant role.
*When providing feedback, be specific and give examples that support your findings. It not enough to say 'event opener', but much more impactful to say ‘using a short story to get your audience engaged was a great way to open the presentation’.
* Relate information in behavior-based terms. ‘You seemed nervous’ could come across as condescending. Rather, saying ‘I noticed you had a hard time making eye contact with participants. Was that because of nerves?’ This opens a dialogue about how to avoid nervousness.
* Include suggestions for improvement. ‘try to engage participants more often’ is more impactful when related this way: ‘during the section were you are explaining widgets, you could ask participants about their widget preferences. Asking questions is a great way to get participants involved’
*Feedback is provided immediately. The sooner feedback is given, the better it can be applied. The event and behaviors are still fresh in both the observer and facilitators minds! I hope this helps
Dawn (Mancour) Wagner